• Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
    • Apologetics
    • Atheism
    • Bible
    • Devotion
    • Church
    • Evangelism
    • Hiddenness of God
    • Leadership
    • Philosophy
    • Religious Pluralism
    • Science and Faith
    • Theology
  • My Books
  • Video
  • Talks
  • Invite Me
No Result
View All Result
Rick Mattson Outreach Ministry
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
    • Apologetics
    • Atheism
    • Bible
    • Devotion
    • Church
    • Evangelism
    • Hiddenness of God
    • Leadership
    • Philosophy
    • Religious Pluralism
    • Science and Faith
    • Theology
  • My Books
  • Video
  • Talks
  • Invite Me
No Result
View All Result
Rick Mattson Outreach Ministry
No Result
View All Result

Responding to Objections 5: “Couldn’t this be explained by . . . “

December 30, 2017

id-100217981-1

From my last post: Why think theism (belief in God) is a better explanation for the world than naturalism (athiesm)?

Here’s one reason. Naturalism struggles to explain the more subjective parts of life, such as consciousness, ethics, art, intention and other mental states.

Two atheist philosophers illustrate the point:

  • Thomas Nagel acknowledges the difficulty of explaining the rise of human consciousness in a purely physical world. How could inanimate matter somehow start to think? (1)
  • Michael Ruse calls the rise of human consciousness the really hard problem, saying, “Here the naturalist is, admittedly, caught flat-footed.” (2)

To be fair to Ruse, he doesn’t think anyone else, including theists, has a better explanation for consciousness. But the point is that in a purely physical/material world, subjective elements such as higher thinking are tough to explain.

A stream cannot rise higher than its source.

But if a personal God has created man and woman in his image, then consciousness and other human traits such as creativity and ethical intuition are to be expected. The stream now flows naturally from its source.

*****

The argument just mentioned doesn’t prove the existence of God. But that’s not the goal. Rather, I’m saying that in one important field, at least — that of consciousness and other non-material parts of life — theism provides a better explanation than naturalism.

Next time: Why a friend thinks miracles are impossible.

 

(1) See chapter 3 of Nagel, Mind and Cosmos: Why the Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature is Almost Certainly False.

(2) See Ruse’s response to Evan Fales in chapter 1 of God and Morality: Four Views.

 

photo courtesy of Poulsen Photo at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

 

 

Share120Tweet75
Rick Mattson

Rick Mattson

Comments 2

  1. Charlie Clauss says:
    7 years ago

    That there is a “zero sum game” between God and nature over causation is a dilemma foisted upon us by Naturalism.

    Reply
    • Rickmattson100 says:
      7 years ago

      Charles, good point. Seems to me that God is free to intervene in our world in any manner he chooses, whether directly — “Let there be light” — or indirectly through the laws of nature which he created. Additionally, there are other indirect means at his disposal — human agents, for example.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Me

Rick Mattson Outreach Ministry

Rick Mattson

Evangelist & Writer

Hello & welcome to my blog! My name is Rick Mattson and I'm a traveling evangelist/apologist.

SUBSCRIBE! You'll be notified by email whenever a new post comes out
Loading

Categories

  • Apologetics (155)
  • Atheism (47)
  • Bible (33)
  • Church (71)
  • Devotion (102)
  • Evangelism (56)
  • Hiddenness of God (9)
  • Leadership (65)
  • Philosophy (7)
  • Religious Pluralism (14)
  • Science and Faith (3)
  • Theology (2)

Popular

  • A Gen Z Additive, Part 1 of 3: Who is Gen Z?

    A Gen Z Additive, Part 1 of 3: Who is Gen Z?

    341 shares
    Share 136 Tweet 85
  • Apologetics for Kids, Part 1 of 2

    336 shares
    Share 134 Tweet 84
  • Tradition as a Guardrail

    327 shares
    Share 131 Tweet 82
  • Apologetics for Kids, Part 2

    320 shares
    Share 128 Tweet 80
  • Muslim Dialogue

    314 shares
    Share 126 Tweet 79
Facebook Twitter

© 2022 Site by 5BCreative

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
    • Apologetics
    • Atheism
    • Bible
    • Devotion
    • Church
    • Evangelism
    • Hiddenness of God
    • Leadership
    • Philosophy
    • Religious Pluralism
    • Science and Faith
    • Theology
  • My Books
  • Video
  • Talks
  • Invite Me